Báo cáo cuối kỳ Global Supply Chain Management Zara’s Supply Chain - Quản trị học | Trường Đại học Kinh tế, Đại học Quốc gia Hà Nội

Báo cáo cuối kỳ Global Supply Chain Management Zara’s Supply Chain - Quản trị học | Trường Đại học Kinh tế, Đại học Quốc gia Hà Nội được sưu tầm và soạn thảo dưới dạng file PDF để gửi tới các bạn sinh viên cùng tham khảo, ôn tập đầy đủ kiến thức, chuẩn bị cho các buổi học thật tốt. Mời bạn đọc đón xem !

lOMoARcPSD|45316467
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
VIETNAM NATIONAL UNIVERSITY, HA NOI
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL
---------o0o---------
FINAL REPORT
GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
ZARA’s Supply Chain
GROUP: 12 Course Code: INS 3021. 01
MEMBERS: Ta Bich Ngoc 19071445
Vu Thi Quynh Anh 19071306
Nguyen Tung Lam 20071018
Nguyen Mai Linh 19071407
LECTURER: PhD Tran Cong Thanh
Hanoi, December 2022
1
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
INDIVIDUAL CONTRIBUTION
Course Name: Global Supply Chain Management
No: ………………………
Course Code: INS 3021. 01 Group No.12
No
Full name
Student
Tasks
Contribution
ID
- About the report
1
Ta Bich Ngoc
19071445
- Zara's supply chain stage
100%
- Supply chain design
2
Vu Thi
19071306
- Zara supply chain management
100%
Quynh Anh issues and practices
3
Nguyen Tung
20072018
- Forecasting
100%
Lam
Nguyen Mai
- Zara’s overview
4 19071407
- Supply chain strategy.
100%
Linh
- Supply chain design
2
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PART A: Introduction................................................................................4
About the report.........................................................................................4
Zara’s Overview.......................................................................................4
PART B: ZARA Supply chain...................................................................5
I. Supply chain stage of Zara...................................................................5
II. Zara’s Lean Supply Chain................................................................7
III. Supply chain design.............................................................................9
PART C: Zara supply chain management issues and practices...........14
I. Relationship management..................................................................14
II. Inventory Management.......................................................................15
III. Reserve Logistics...............................................................................17
IV. Forecasting.........................................................................................18
REFERENCES:........................................................................................21
APPENDIX:...............................................................................................24
SELF ASSESSMENT:..............................................................................28
3
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
PART A: Introduction
About the report
The purpose of this study is to evaluate and assess Zara's worldwide supply chain
strategy and management priorities. A high-level overview of Zara's supply chain is
given in the article. In order to manage the supply chain sustainably and at the lowest
possible cost, we looked at the challenges the organization faced and how they operated,
and offered suggestions for enhancing Zara's supply chain to make it more effective and
ideal.
Zara’s Overview
Zara is a Spanish clothing retailer based in Galicia, Spain. Founded by Amancio Ortega
in 1975, it is the flagship chain store of the Inditex group, one of the world's largest
apparel retailers. It has stores in 96 countries and is the flagship brand of the Inditex
Group. Zara is renowned for its ability to develop a new product and get it to stores
within two weeks, while other retailers take six months.
Zara’s mission is to give the customer what they want and give it to them faster than
anyone else. Zara’s vision is to contribute to the sustainable development of society and
that of the environment with which we interact." (Edrawsoft, 2022).
Since Zara is one of the most successful fast fashion brands, they aim to rapidly respond
to the demands of customers at affordable prices, we can see that their business strategy
is vertical integration. It adapts couture designs, manufactures, distributes, and retails
clothes within two weeks of the original design first appearing on catwalks. This is in
stark contrast to the average six months it takes to produce items in the fashion industry.
The company owns its supply chain and competes on its speed to market, literally
embodying the idea of 'fast fashion' (QuickBooks, 2018).
4
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
PART B: ZARA Supply chain
I. Supply chain stage of Zara
Zara recently revealed that it will use its physical locations to fulfill internet orders.
The news highlights Zara's prior tactical accomplishments. Zara has put in place a
supply management system that makes use of RFID garment tracking technology to do
this. The technology will connect inventory data across brick-and-mortar stores and
internet fulfillment sites. When traditional fulfillment centers run out of inventory, this
will allow retailers to fill internet orders.
The development also demonstrates Zara's prior efforts to improve supply chain
effectiveness. In less than 25 days, Zara has been able to design, produce, ship, and
sell new clothing. This frees the merchant from having to transport clothing from
Asia and enables them to adapt to rapidly changing consumer tastes (a process which
can take many months).
(CB Insights, 2018)
5
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
1. Input material
Zara's major design headquarters are in Spain, and the company maintains close ties
with its offices and purchasing systems throughout the world, including those in
Hong Kong, Beijing, Barcelona,...
The business buys low-cost raw materials from numerous nations, including Spain,
India, the Middle East,..., with the quantity determined by the proper dyed/undyed ratio.
Undyed fabrics support the brand's ability to adapt quickly and flexibly to each unique
Zara campaign.
2. Producing finished goods
The design team at Zara focuses on adhering to existing fashion trends rather than
striving to establish new ones and releases roughly 15,000 new designs annually.
This makes it simpler for Zara to consistently have a source of items and to
occasionally produce in line with trends (without the pressure of new breakthroughs,
creating new fashion trends).
The manufacturing process at Zara firmly abides by the Just In Time philosophy; items
are produced in accordance with the appropriate standards, using the appropriate
models, in the appropriate locations, and at the appropriate times. This operational
principle aims to maintain uniform operation by eliminating inefficient procedures. The
production capacity of Zara's factories is always between 85-100%, and can be
increased if necessary to help the company always control the quantity, speed and new
products launched to the market.
3. Storage and distribution operations
Competing retailers' inventories are less than half as Zara. In particular, compared to the
average inventory level of 1720% maintained by many companies in the industry, the
corporation maintains an inventory level of less than 10%.
More than 450 million products may be handled by Zara's supply chain annually, and
new product models are introduced twice a week. Statistics show that the corporation
can deliver huge volumes of goods to stores in its retail network in Europe within 24
hours and in the Americas and Asia within 40 hours. After delivery, products can be
6
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
sold right away to clients.The high, stable production schedule and quick delivery time of
the Zara supply chain help the company to stay close to the needs of its customers.
4. Supplying items to consumers (through the retail chain)
The corporation concentrates on creating and running supply chains, famous and
distinctive display places, and less on public relations and advertising operations.
For this business, the "focal point" of viral communication is its customers.
II. Zara’s Lean Supply Chain
To be successful in the fashion and textile business, it’s hard for most businesses to
predict the demand changes because of the fashion trends and volatile market. The rapidly
changing demand could change in a short time, giving business’s supply chain a
hard time. The way to stay strong and stand out in this business is using Lean in their
supply chain strategy and Zara is a brand that is successful in using it.
1. Pull strategy (Kanban)
One of the Lean techniques for their supply chain is the Pull strategy, or Kanban. Using
a pulling approach helps ZARA reduce the bullwhip effect, avoid over-producing and
over-ordering, the Kanban system keeps small quantities of resources that are needed
and replaces what is used, only when it has been used.
ZARA creates up to 1,000 designs every month based on store sales and current
trends. It monitors how much money customers spend in store to evaluate and
understand which designs are being purchased and then it updates its next designs
accordingly (Robinson, 2015).
Zara has used pull as their approach. If the other shops design their own collections and
push them to the other retailers, or their own shops, Zara decided to create what their
customers want. In the saleling, Zara’s store employees always listen to the customers’
feedback and after that, they will tell them to the designer team in Arteixo. They also
produce small batches of new designs to test the interest of consumers and thus decide
what designs to mass-produce (Technology and Operations Management, 2015).
7
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
2. Just In Time
Zara, which is famous for setting trends ahead of its competitors, often updates its
clothing designs every two weeks. Zara uses Just-in-Time (JIT) production techniques
to ensure turnaround times as short as possible in order to keep up with this breakneck
pace. JIT is a unique method that, when well designed and implemented, has several
benefits that aren't restricted to cost savings. Zara manufactures a large portion of its
products in-house, with many of its facilities located near the company's headquarters in
Galicia, Spain. It also keeps around 85% of capacity available for any necessary in-
season adjustments, providing for greater flexibility and agility in how and when new
items are introduced. They are able to give their customers the latest fashion every
month by utilizing customer psychology and combining it with a production process
that saves them money and time.
When there are must- have items, or a new fashion trend on the street, Zara’s
designers will get to work as soon as possible. They come up with inventive style,
then bring it to the store while it is still trending. This time, the store managers and
sales employees will communicate with customers, then give feedback to the designers
about what their customers like, what they think about the trend lately,.. This will
create demand forecasting data and it is sent to the designers immediately, so that they
can start to sketch and start to produce a large number and customers will visit to buy.
Zara changes its apparel designs every two weeks on average; most of its competitors
do so every 1014 weeks. It is a little bit risky of Zara to have their products from the
factories straight to shelves, this is a priceless strategy.
3. Flexibility
The production of their products is highly flexible. Their seasonal designs are what their
consumers asked for. It allows rapid response after the customers’ demand. Zara’s
fabric before designing are plain and uncolored, Zara is again able to respond to trends or
consumer demands, dyeing the fabrics according to whichever color happens to be on-
season or is required for a particular clothing design (Worldfinance.com, 2015).
Zara produces seasonal-collection every year and sells fresh models all year around.
They adapt their items according to the client's needs, fashion trends and store sales.
8
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
Zara is also sensible, if one of their designs does not work out, they will retire it. They
made a thousand designs per month and updated their collections. By making
shipments every two weeks, this quick turnover enables businesses to provide fresh
designs, luring customers in again and time again.
4. Cost
From years to years, Zara always offers unique, high quality, latest fashionable products
to their customers at an affordable price. Zara’s production labor cost in Asia is
quite cheap, compared with inside Spain, for that reason, Zara must therefore offer a
higher price than its rivals who have completely outsourced their manufacture to Asian
nations. Considering what clients are willing to pay, they determine rates based on
geography using a demand-oriented approach.
III. Supply chain design
To take advantage of the fast fashion aspect, Zara follows the vertical integration. It
will help the supply chain run smoothly. By acquiring businesses at different stages of
the chain, Zara is able to maintain better control of the value chain, which means it
can react quickly to shifting consumer demands (Thomasnet.com, 2020).
1. Marketing
The Marketing Function (Nada R. Sanders, 2018).
With the dramatic introduction and the crowded fast fashion market, it will be hard for
fashion brands to stand out, and Zara made it. Zara understands their market segment
9
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
and what their target customers and from that, they can make them different from
their competitors.
Zara’s market segmentation is diversity, they have products for men, women, kids.
Their products do not stop at clothes. Beside clothes, they also have home products,
accessories, etc. Zara provides a significantly larger assortment of styles and designs
with over 450 million products per year, compared to average retailers. They focus on
their modern design and they assure its inventory is always refreshed for its clients.
Without outsourcing the manufacture, Zara is ready to quickly react to market changes
and fashion turns. The production and distribution time are also reduced, Zara tries to
have trending products for sale as fast as possible. Clothes in the stores are kept short,
this will keep customers coming back to the store and trying to buy before it is sold
out. Zara keeps their expense in the promotion and advertising low to achieve balance,
and maintain the competitive advantage of low prices (Edrawsoft, 2022).
Zara also does its marketing through distribution channels. Zara distribution strategy
is one of the key elements behind its quick response strategy. Zara has outlets in 86
countries, including Europe, United States, Middle East and Asia. In 2012, Inditex, the
parent company of Zara claimed US$20.7 billion of total sales, out of which Zara
contributed 66 percent that is US$13.6 billion sales, which is a huge success
(hussain1108, 2015).
Zara focused mainly on opening new stores and word of mouth. Their key
promotion strategy is based on experience, exclusivity, affordability, and
differentiation. They understand women, their main target customers.
2. Retailing Operation
Currently Zara has about 1,763 stores worldwide. After 5 years of entering the
Vietnamese market, Zara currently only has a system of stores in two major cities of
Vietnam: Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City.
To rapidly match changing customer’s needs, Zara practices total control of the retail-
chain through forward integration and retaining ownership of 90% of its stores (Sull &
Turconi, 2008). Zara uses franchise only in risky countries or in countries where wholly
10
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
owned stores are not allowed to operate (Tokatli, 2008). However, Zara’s franchise
agreements are usually designed as a 5-year contract with fees of 5-10% of total sales
and Zara always reserves the right to either buy out the franchisee or open wholly
owned stores during that contract period. This arrangement allows Zara to experiment
markets in new countries without bearing significant financial risk (Caro & Martínez-
de-Albéniz, 2015). Given that consumers increasingly choose to purchase online for the
best deals, Zara's plan to expand its retail space may be in jeopardy at this
point."Consumers are changing their shopping habits. Instead of going to sub-stores,
they are more likely to shop online but still value flagship stores with good locations,"
said Alistair Wittet, head category manager European investment at Comgest - one of
20 investors of Inditex. A modest change in retail orders, for instance, can result in wide
variation in orders as it reaches the factory while being transmitted through wholesalers
and distributors (Whang & Lee, 1998). Additionally, it gives Zara more sway over retail
inventories in terms of product mix, pricing and quantity offered and other factors. The
level of control achieved allows Zara to set the pace at which products and information
flow (Edmondson, 2003).
Zara places the stores in prime locations that attract a voluminous flow of upscale
shoppers in the most high-profile commercial areas, often including landmark buildings
in the premier shopping streets and upscale shopping centers around the world. The
average size of the stores is 1200-1,376 square meters and carries about 40,000 units of
inventory. Shop floors are designed to be spacious and therefore the product density of a
typical Zara store is 28 units of inventory per square meter while traditional retailers
usually have between 32 and 43 units of inventory per square meter. Zara erected a
three-story store in the charming downtown area of Bilbao, a sizable city in northern
Spain, complete with stone pillars and chandeliers hanging from the roof. three smaller
stores were closed, along with marble and vibrant glass windows.
3. Internal Manufacturing and Outsourcing
3.1. Outsourcing
With the vertical integrated, Zara is helped to reduce risk and maintain better control of the
value chain, and easily to shifting consumer demands. Zara outsourcing is minimal,
11
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
it helps Zara control everything from design to display to shipping, allowing it to gather
valuable data at every stage (Thomasnet.com, 2020).
Zara outsources the fashion products to original design manufacturers in countries that
are near each other. This will help to compress order- to- delivery lead times (Gereffi &
Memedovic, 2003; Tokatli, 2008). By using outsourcing, Zara can quickly cancel the
out of trend products and avoid inventory backlogs and product markdowns that are a
regular drain on profit (Tokatli, 2008). To compare production in Europe and Asia,
Europe’s labor is higher than Zara by about 15- 20%, Asia countries are far but the
labor cost is cheaper and crowder. Zara procures the more price-sensitive but less time-
sensitive basic category apparel products by outsourcing total production processes to
OEM production/full package sourcing networks located in distant sources such as
China, Bangladesh, India, Pakistan, Vietnam and Cambodia where labor wage rates are
lower and order-to-delivery lead times are significantly longer compared to
local/proximate sourcing (Ferdows et al., 2004; Inditex Annual Report, 2005).
3.2. Internal Manufacture
The internal manufacturing is performed by 11 fully owned plants, most of them
positioned in and around Zara’s headquarters in Arteixo, Northern Spain (Amed &
Abnett, 2015) and (Inditex Annual Report, 2017). The manufacturing facilities are
automated and only perform in the capital-intensive initial production like fabric
dyeing; pattern design using CAD; creating layout of pattern pieces, cutting fabric by
automate knives and lasers aided by computer aided manufacturing (CAM). These
machines can calculate how to position the layout of pattern pieces on the marker
efficiently and quickly on computer screens to map out the individual parts for a
garment on the fabric. The machine thus minimizes fabric waste while cutting over 100
layers of cloth at single cut (Ghemawat & Nueno, 2006; McAfee et al., 2007).
After the fabrics are cutted, it will be sent to a network of more than 400-450 partner
factories located nearby the Inditex-owned factories in Galicia and Portugal to perform
the labor intensive assembly/sewing operations. Zara attentively monitors their
partner’s operation to safeguard quality, conformity with labor laws, and above
all else adherence to the production schedule. Zara and its subcontractors are generally
long-term and as such Zara collaborates with its subcontracting partners by providing
12
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
technology, logistics and financial support. After that, the partner factories then bring
back the assembled items to Zara’s factories, where each piece is inspected for
quality control during ironing, given a machine-readable tag and packaged. The
finished products are then dispatched on hangers grouped by model and size, through
part of the 211 km network of rails to Zara’s Arteixo distribution center. Completed
products procured from external suppliers are also sent directly to the distribution
center. Zara implements a sampling methodology to ensure quality for the incoming
products (Ghemawat & Nueno, 2006).
4. Logistics and Distribution
Logistics entails the free circulation of commodities from production units to target 1
customer for total satisfaction. It incorporates the integration of information, movement
of goods, stocking, storage, casing, and safety (Gelder & Woodcock, 2003). Zara has
successful logistics that totally commits to the customer's satisfaction. The effectiveness
of time and location are enhanced by its logistics. The business makes sure that clothing
is sent from its production facility in a timely manner to different outlets throughout the
world. It takes into account the constantly shifting fashion and trends that affect the
textile sector, enduring the constantly shifting consumer needs. Depending on the
requirements and market niche of that particular region, the logistics department
considers supplying different retailers with a variety of supplies. The company's
manufacturing operations are described in the following details: Instead of focusing on
low prices and cheap labor, Zara competes on flexibility and agility. Compared to the
average labor cost in Asia, which is roughly 0.40 euros per hour, they employ about
3,000 people in manufacturing operations in Spain at an average cost of 8.00 euros per
hour. Flexible manufacturing systems are used in the Spanish Zara facilities to facilitate
quick operational changes: 50% of all items are manufactured in Spain, 26% in the rest
of Europe, 24% in Asia and Africa.
Due to Zara's robust distribution network, products may be delivered to its European
stores in less than 24 hours and to its American and Asian locations in under 40. The
Cube and the company's headquarters are both in northwest Spain, which is the region's
center for manufacturing. However, they went with a location that is more centrally
positioned for its primary distribution and logistical hub. That facility is situated in a
sizable logistics hub built by the Spanish government in Zaragoza. Suppliers deliver raw
13
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
materials to Zara's production facility. After that, finished clothing is removed from
the Cube and delivered to the Zara logistics center in Zaragoza. From there, they are
transported by truck and by airplane.
PART C: Zara supply chain management issues and practices
I.Relationship management
1. Issues
Lack of Supplier Relationship Management brings Zara under fire. Reports from major
publications, such as Newsweek, have accused Zara of not paying its employees.
Stakeholders and advocates for human rights have expressed their displeasure with
this. (Newsweek, 2017)
2. Practices
Managing supplier relationships - and ensuring procurement and sourcing activities are
completed ethically - is now more important than ever. Zara's trust-based and power-
based relationships with suppliers have allowed the company to operate with virtually
few inventory in the process.
“According to the AP news agency, one of the factories owned by a Turkish Zara
company, Bravo, has been accused of not paying employees on time, if any” (Kaye,
2017). Zara customers find notes from unpaid employees inside their clothes. This lack
of relationship management regarding these external entities has once again put Zara
in the hot seat.
In 2017, Zara signed an agreement with the International Labor Organization to
develop "best practices" in its factories and working conditions. However, just a month
later, these accusations surfaced and Zara did not make any public statements regarding
the allegations about their activities in Bravo factories.
3. Recommendations
Zara takes the fact that suppliers and manufacturers are the foundations of any business
extremely seriously and cares equally for its suppliers and producers. It effectively
14
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
protects the human rights of workers who toil away to make those stylish garments a
reality. Zara's long-term business model contributes to the development and prosperity
of its suppliers. As a result, it has a favorable impact in a number of countries. Zara
also works to promote international labor conventions. It demonstrates how the
corporation not only cares about its customers, but also for its suppliers and producers.
After all, Zara would be nothing without its employees at all levels.
II. Inventory Management
1. Issues
When applying lean production, Zara faces inventory management issues that mean
improving their supply chain and running it in a short time (about 15 days/new product)
while controlling operating and inventory costs as low as possible.
2. Practices
This model is used to minimize the cost to determine the purchasing as well as repairing
of lot sizes, predicts the sales in the store throughout the replenishment period, reduces
15
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
the shipment time, boosts the proportion of time that the products of Zara spend
on exhibit in their lifecycle. Thus, regarding competitors, Zara's inventory level is
the lowest.
Firstly, Zara launches only small batch productions (lean concept) in order to reduce the
risks of producing something the customer doesn’t want. Thus, they reduced the
number of unsold clothes and practiced less markdowns than the others which increased
the profit margin.
Moreover, Zara employs postponement for instance half of the products are undyed
until the last moment to select the color. That method decreases the components stock
and avoids forecasting mistakes.
Furthermore, it sometimes occurs that a product is sold well in one country but not in
another one, Zara uses reverse logistics by moving stocks from a store to another one
in order to place this product in a country where the sales will be higher. Stores place
orders twice a week and they don’t keep stock in the stores which decreases the stock
level as well. They can do that because of the speed of replenishment (within 24
hours in European countries).
3. Recommendations
Quick response (QR) began in the apparel industry as a response to JIT practices of the
auto industry. Zara should continue to develop a QR strategy that is based on shortening
the lead time from product design to store display because it allows the supply chain to
enter the seasonal sales cycle with a small initial inventory allocation at the retailers,
observe early sales patterns, generate a posterior demand distribution, and choose the
optimal replenishment quantity to maximize expected profits given the posterior
distribution. In this manner, Zara's planned stock-outs become a marketing advantage,
and they also avoid inventory obsolescence costs by quickly responding to changes in
the marketplace.
Zara should be more careful about the way it deploys the latest IT tools to facilitate
information exchanges and apply advances of Technologies to produce more in less
time. A small change in retail orders can result in wide fluctuations in factory orders
after it's transmitted through wholesalers and distributors. In an industry that
16
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
traditionally allows retailers to change a maximum of 20% of their orders once the
season has started, Zara lets them adjust 40-50% => Zara can avoid costly over
production and the subsequent sales and discounting prevalent in the industry
III. Reserve Logistics
The Zara organization makes some improvement in their supply chain and lastly they go
for reverse logistics of their clothes to become more sustainable.
1. Issues
Zara’s customers return products to different locations around the world
=> The collection and redemption process to reuse, recycle or refurbish old products
takes time and is complicated.
2. Practices
Zara uses reverse logistics by moving stocks from a store to another one to place them
in a country where the sales will be higher, buying their old clothes for a small price
to reuse or organizing the reverse logistics for the returning parcels and re-introducing
them back to the commercial circuit.
In fact, as the clothes are fast-fashion items, basically, they quickly become “has-
been”. Zara could buy their old clothes for a small price to reuse the material. Zara
could create a closed loop by bringing back the products from the point of consumption
to the point of origin. Both Zara and customers would be winners. For sure, this
solution is hard to implement. If Zara organizes the reverse logistics for the returning
parcels and re-introducing them, The returned package needs to be opened and checked,
the clothes probably ironed, refolded and repacked. Then they need to be sent back to
the usual logistic flow.
In short, dealing with ‘revitalizing’ clothes implies a cost (in money and time). Time
devoted to returning shipping, revitalizing clothes, and introducing the items again to
logistic-commercial flow means losing the freshness of trendy products, which have
‘‘expiration date’’ approach by the minute. This is especially troublesome in the
case of Zara.
17
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
3. Recommendations
In the long-term,Zara should work with third party transportation suppliers who are
close to its retail locations and are knowledgeable with the local transit infrastructure.
They will know the best way for faster delivery when having a product transported in
a local location that may have traffic jams or geographical difficulties. Furthermore,
buyers who are interested in Zara items and want to buy in quantity can choose a third
party to provide things to them as quickly as possible. In addition, Zara should widely
promote the campaign to recall old products for recycling in parallel with the launch of
a new collection to attract and stimulate buying psychology.
IV. Forecasting
1. Overview
Zara's method is reactive, responding to market demand before it happens, which gives
Zara the possibility of planning ahead for styles and quantity. Zara forecasting strategy
focuses on responding to customer demands in a timely and cost-effective manner.
Zara's strategy also focuses on acquiring and provides the company with the vital
information it needs to stay competitive. They are quick on tech innovation and
even quicker on customer reactivity.
Trend forecasting allows Zara to keep close tabs on its customers’ desires in real
time. Customer’s demand is their priority . Besides, they want to ensure that the
right product is available in the right place at the right time. This strategy helps the
company to reduce costs and boost sales. Specifically, the forecasting process takes
into account both the internal and external factors that can affect consumer demand
(McCann & Husmini, 2017).
2. Issues
Zara is quite active in releasing collections every few weeks. This way ensures to
keep customers coming back and keep designers aware of client feedback and
demand. However, it puts the burden on the inventory due to shortages and out-of-
stock situations (Mollard, 2020). They have difficulties making short-term forecast
18
lOMoARcPSD|45316467
Group 12 | INS 3021 01
judgments since they have to process large amounts of quantitative data such as initial
stock shipments to retailers, inventory replenishment, liquidation pricing, and supplier
purchase quantities. Furthermore, these choices are sometimes in the hands of a few
professionals. If they depart, it will create serious problems for the organization (Clegg,
2015).
Zara lags behind in AI-powered trend forecasting. They are unable to extend their
significant market share in e-commerce as a result of this (Gosselin, 2020). Actual e-
commerce demand is different from offline demand. It made product planning, design
development, garment production, and resource sharing
problematic. This results in higher production costs and autonomous development
while still consuming supplier capacity (Song, 2021).
3. Zara implement forecasting
By forecasting trend behaviors and obtaining the data it can help merchandising and
planning teams align with design teams to adjust quantities, this will help Zara to focus
more on other strategies like reducing the amount of time for introducing new products .
Trend forecasting can be a practical way for Zara’s collection planning strategy. Zara’s
Quantitative analysis of social channels deep dives into consumer needs, and
this technology can predict trends up to one year in advance.
Zara's demand forecasting tends to be customer-centric, it helps Zara sustain and retain
competitive advantages over other rivals. Sales tracking data allows Zara to cater to its
customers with new trends and eliminate designs that do not appeal to customers. They
collect real-time data from e-commercial and store it through PDA , POS , RFID
tag, and SKU’s.
To deal with qualitative data problems, Zara has developed Operations Research
and Information Technology divisions. These will find ways to deal
with the input data and use the optimization model to give the most accurate
forecast results (Clegg, 2015). Zara’s design team looks at sales data from stores
around the world to forecast what will be top-selling items and adjust
designs accordingly. They also receive qualitative feedback from in-store employees .
Moreover, collecting real data is helpful to forecast the amount of quantities and price
points for the new designs (Uberoi, 2017). To solve the problems of
19
| 1/30

Preview text:

lOMoARcPSD|45316467 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
VIETNAM NATIONAL UNIVERSITY, HA NOI INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL ---------o0o--------- FINAL REPORT
GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT ZARA’s Supply Chain GROUP: 12
Course Code: INS 3021. 01 MEMBERS: Ta Bich Ngoc 19071445 Vu Thi Quynh Anh 19071306 Nguyen Tung Lam 20071018 Nguyen Mai Linh 19071407 LECTURER: PhD Tran Cong Thanh Hanoi, December 2022 1 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01 INDIVIDUAL CONTRIBUTION
Course Name: Global Supply Chain Management
No: ……………………… Course Code: INS 3021. 01 Group No.12 Student No Full name Tasks Contribution ID - About the report 1 Ta Bich Ngoc
19071445 - Zara's supply chain stage 100% - Supply chain design Vu Thi - Zara supply chain management 2 19071306 100% Quynh Anh issues and practices Nguyen Tung 3 20072018 - Forecasting 100% Lam Nguyen Mai - Zara’s overview 4
19071407 - Supply chain strategy. 100% Linh - Supply chain design 2 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01 TABLE OF CONTENTS
PART A: Introduction................................................................................4
About the report.........................................................................................4
Zara’s Overview.......................................................................................4
PART B: ZARA Supply chain...................................................................5
I. Supply chain stage of Zara...................................................................5
II. Zara’s Lean Supply Chain................................................................7
III. Supply chain design.............................................................................9
PART C: Zara supply chain management issues and practices...........14
I. Relationship management..................................................................14
II. Inventory Management.......................................................................15
III. Reserve Logistics...............................................................................17
IV. Forecasting.........................................................................................18
REFERENCES:........................................................................................21
APPENDIX:...............................................................................................24
SELF ASSESSMENT:..............................................................................28 3 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01 PART A: Introduction About the report
The purpose of this study is to evaluate and assess Zara's worldwide supply chain
strategy and management priorities. A high-level overview of Zara's supply chain is
given in the article. In order to manage the supply chain sustainably and at the lowest
possible cost, we looked at the challenges the organization faced and how they operated,
and offered suggestions for enhancing Zara's supply chain to make it more effective and ideal. Zara’s Overview
Zara is a Spanish clothing retailer based in Galicia, Spain. Founded by Amancio Ortega
in 1975, it is the flagship chain store of the Inditex group, one of the world's largest
apparel retailers. It has stores in 96 countries and is the flagship brand of the Inditex
Group. Zara is renowned for its ability to develop a new product and get it to stores
within two weeks, while other retailers take six months.
Zara’s mission is to give the customer what they want and give it to them faster than
anyone else. Zara’s vision is to contribute to the sustainable development of society and
that of the environment with which we interact." (Edrawsoft, 2022).
Since Zara is one of the most successful fast fashion brands, they aim to rapidly respond
to the demands of customers at affordable prices, we can see that their business strategy
is vertical integration. It adapts couture designs, manufactures, distributes, and retails
clothes within two weeks of the original design first appearing on catwalks. This is in
stark contrast to the average six months it takes to produce items in the fashion industry.
The company owns its supply chain and competes on its speed to market, literally
embodying the idea of 'fast fashion' (QuickBooks, 2018). 4 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
PART B: ZARA Supply chain I.
Supply chain stage of Zara
Zara recently revealed that it will use its physical locations to fulfill internet orders.
The news highlights Zara's prior tactical accomplishments. Zara has put in place a
supply management system that makes use of RFID garment tracking technology to do
this. The technology will connect inventory data across brick-and-mortar stores and
internet fulfillment sites. When traditional fulfillment centers run out of inventory, this
will allow retailers to fill internet orders.
The development also demonstrates Zara's prior efforts to improve supply chain
effectiveness. In less than 25 days, Zara has been able to design, produce, ship, and
sell new clothing. This frees the merchant from having to transport clothing from
Asia and enables them to adapt to rapidly changing consumer tastes (a process which can take many months). (CB Insights, 2018) 5 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01 1. Input material
Zara's major design headquarters are in Spain, and the company maintains close ties
with its offices and purchasing systems throughout the world, including those in
Hong Kong, Beijing, Barcelona,...
The business buys low-cost raw materials from numerous nations, including Spain,
India, the Middle East,..., with the quantity determined by the proper dyed/undyed ratio.
Undyed fabrics support the brand's ability to adapt quickly and flexibly to each unique Zara campaign.
2. Producing finished goods
The design team at Zara focuses on adhering to existing fashion trends rather than
striving to establish new ones and releases roughly 15,000 new designs annually.
This makes it simpler for Zara to consistently have a source of items and to
occasionally produce in line with trends (without the pressure of new breakthroughs, creating new fashion trends).
The manufacturing process at Zara firmly abides by the Just In Time philosophy; items
are produced in accordance with the appropriate standards, using the appropriate
models, in the appropriate locations, and at the appropriate times. This operational
principle aims to maintain uniform operation by eliminating inefficient procedures. The
production capacity of Zara's factories is always between 85-100%, and can be
increased if necessary to help the company always control the quantity, speed and new
products launched to the market.
3. Storage and distribution operations
Competing retailers' inventories are less than half as Zara. In particular, compared to the
average inventory level of 1720% maintained by many companies in the industry, the
corporation maintains an inventory level of less than 10%.
More than 450 million products may be handled by Zara's supply chain annually, and
new product models are introduced twice a week. Statistics show that the corporation
can deliver huge volumes of goods to stores in its retail network in Europe within 24
hours and in the Americas and Asia within 40 hours. After delivery, products can be 6 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
sold right away to clients.The high, stable production schedule and quick delivery time of
the Zara supply chain help the company to stay close to the needs of its customers.
4. Supplying items to consumers (through the retail chain)
The corporation concentrates on creating and running supply chains, famous and
distinctive display places, and less on public relations and advertising operations.
For this business, the "focal point" of viral communication is its customers. II.
Zara’s Lean Supply Chain
To be successful in the fashion and textile business, it’s hard for most businesses to
predict the demand changes because of the fashion trends and volatile market. The rapidly
changing demand could change in a short time, giving business’s supply chain a
hard time. The way to stay strong and stand out in this business is using Lean in their
supply chain strategy and Zara is a brand that is successful in using it.
1. Pull strategy (Kanban)
One of the Lean techniques for their supply chain is the Pull strategy, or Kanban. Using
a pulling approach helps ZARA reduce the bullwhip effect, avoid over-producing and
over-ordering, the Kanban system keeps small quantities of resources that are needed
and replaces what is used, only when it has been used.
ZARA creates up to 1,000 designs every month based on store sales and current
trends. It monitors how much money customers spend in store to evaluate and
understand which designs are being purchased and then it updates its next designs accordingly (Robinson, 2015).
Zara has used pull as their approach. If the other shops design their own collections and
push them to the other retailers, or their own shops, Zara decided to create what their
customers want. In the saleling, Zara’s store employees always listen to the customers’
feedback and after that, they will tell them to the designer team in Arteixo. They also
produce small batches of new designs to test the interest of consumers and thus decide
what designs to mass-produce (Technology and Operations Management, 2015). 7 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01 2. Just In Time
Zara, which is famous for setting trends ahead of its competitors, often updates its
clothing designs every two weeks. Zara uses Just-in-Time (JIT) production techniques
to ensure turnaround times as short as possible in order to keep up with this breakneck
pace. JIT is a unique method that, when well designed and implemented, has several
benefits that aren't restricted to cost savings. Zara manufactures a large portion of its
products in-house, with many of its facilities located near the company's headquarters in
Galicia, Spain. It also keeps around 85% of capacity available for any necessary in-
season adjustments, providing for greater flexibility and agility in how and when new
items are introduced. They are able to give their customers the latest fashion every
month by utilizing customer psychology and combining it with a production process
that saves them money and time.
When there are must- have items, or a new fashion trend on the street, Zara’s
designers will get to work as soon as possible. They come up with inventive style,
then bring it to the store while it is still trending. This time, the store managers and
sales employees will communicate with customers, then give feedback to the designers
about what their customers like, what they think about the trend lately,.. This will
create demand forecasting data and it is sent to the designers immediately, so that they
can start to sketch and start to produce a large number and customers will visit to buy.
Zara changes its apparel designs every two weeks on average; most of its competitors
do so every 1014 weeks. It is a little bit risky of Zara to have their products from the
factories straight to shelves, this is a priceless strategy. 3. Flexibility
The production of their products is highly flexible. Their seasonal designs are what their
consumers asked for. It allows rapid response after the customers’ demand. Zara’s
fabric before designing are plain and uncolored, Zara is again able to respond to trends or
consumer demands, dyeing the fabrics according to whichever color happens to be on-
season or is required for a particular clothing design (Worldfinance.com, 2015).
Zara produces seasonal-collection every year and sells fresh models all year around.
They adapt their items according to the client's needs, fashion trends and store sales. 8 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
Zara is also sensible, if one of their designs does not work out, they will retire it. They
made a thousand designs per month and updated their collections. By making
shipments every two weeks, this quick turnover enables businesses to provide fresh
designs, luring customers in again and time again. 4. Cost
From years to years, Zara always offers unique, high quality, latest fashionable products
to their customers at an affordable price. Zara’s production labor cost in Asia is
quite cheap, compared with inside Spain, for that reason, Zara must therefore offer a
higher price than its rivals who have completely outsourced their manufacture to Asian
nations. Considering what clients are willing to pay, they determine rates based on
geography using a demand-oriented approach.
III. Supply chain design
To take advantage of the fast fashion aspect, Zara follows the vertical integration. It
will help the supply chain run smoothly. By acquiring businesses at different stages of
the chain, Zara is able to maintain better control of the value chain, which means it
can react quickly to shifting consumer demands (Thomasnet.com, 2020). 1. Marketing
The Marketing Function (Nada R. Sanders, 2018).
With the dramatic introduction and the crowded fast fashion market, it will be hard for
fashion brands to stand out, and Zara made it. Zara understands their market segment 9 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
and what their target customers and from that, they can make them different from their competitors.
Zara’s market segmentation is diversity, they have products for men, women, kids.
Their products do not stop at clothes. Beside clothes, they also have home products,
accessories, etc. Zara provides a significantly larger assortment of styles and designs
with over 450 million products per year, compared to average retailers. They focus on
their modern design and they assure its inventory is always refreshed for its clients.
Without outsourcing the manufacture, Zara is ready to quickly react to market changes
and fashion turns. The production and distribution time are also reduced, Zara tries to
have trending products for sale as fast as possible. Clothes in the stores are kept short,
this will keep customers coming back to the store and trying to buy before it is sold
out. Zara keeps their expense in the promotion and advertising low to achieve balance,
and maintain the competitive advantage of low prices (Edrawsoft, 2022).
Zara also does its marketing through distribution channels. Zara distribution strategy
is one of the key elements behind its quick response strategy. Zara has outlets in 86
countries, including Europe, United States, Middle East and Asia. In 2012, Inditex, the
parent company of Zara claimed US$20.7 billion of total sales, out of which Zara
contributed 66 percent that is US$13.6 billion sales, which is a huge success (hussain1108, 2015).
Zara focused mainly on opening new stores and word of mouth. Their key
promotion strategy is based on experience, exclusivity, affordability, and
differentiation. They understand women, their main target customers. 2. Retailing Operation
Currently Zara has about 1,763 stores worldwide. After 5 years of entering the
Vietnamese market, Zara currently only has a system of stores in two major cities of
Vietnam: Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City.
To rapidly match changing customer’s needs, Zara practices total control of the retail-
chain through forward integration and retaining ownership of 90% of its stores (Sull &
Turconi, 2008). Zara uses franchise only in risky countries or in countries where wholly 10 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
owned stores are not allowed to operate (Tokatli, 2008). However, Zara’s franchise
agreements are usually designed as a 5-year contract with fees of 5-10% of total sales
and Zara always reserves the right to either buy out the franchisee or open wholly
owned stores during that contract period. This arrangement allows Zara to experiment
markets in new countries without bearing significant financial risk (Caro & Martínez-
de-Albéniz, 2015). Given that consumers increasingly choose to purchase online for the
best deals, Zara's plan to expand its retail space may be in jeopardy at this
point."Consumers are changing their shopping habits. Instead of going to sub-stores,
they are more likely to shop online but still value flagship stores with good locations,"
said Alistair Wittet, head category manager European investment at Comgest - one of
20 investors of Inditex. A modest change in retail orders, for instance, can result in wide
variation in orders as it reaches the factory while being transmitted through wholesalers
and distributors (Whang & Lee, 1998). Additionally, it gives Zara more sway over retail
inventories in terms of product mix, pricing and quantity offered and other factors. The
level of control achieved allows Zara to set the pace at which products and information flow (Edmondson, 2003).
Zara places the stores in prime locations that attract a voluminous flow of upscale
shoppers in the most high-profile commercial areas, often including landmark buildings
in the premier shopping streets and upscale shopping centers around the world. The
average size of the stores is 1200-1,376 square meters and carries about 40,000 units of
inventory. Shop floors are designed to be spacious and therefore the product density of a
typical Zara store is 28 units of inventory per square meter while traditional retailers
usually have between 32 and 43 units of inventory per square meter. Zara erected a
three-story store in the charming downtown area of Bilbao, a sizable city in northern
Spain, complete with stone pillars and chandeliers hanging from the roof. three smaller
stores were closed, along with marble and vibrant glass windows.
3. Internal Manufacturing and Outsourcing 3.1. Outsourcing
With the vertical integrated, Zara is helped to reduce risk and maintain better control of the
value chain, and easily to shifting consumer demands. Zara outsourcing is minimal, 11 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
it helps Zara control everything from design to display to shipping, allowing it to gather
valuable data at every stage (Thomasnet.com, 2020).
Zara outsources the fashion products to original design manufacturers in countries that
are near each other. This will help to compress order- to- delivery lead times (Gereffi &
Memedovic, 2003; Tokatli, 2008). By using outsourcing, Zara can quickly cancel the
out of trend products and avoid inventory backlogs and product markdowns that are a
regular drain on profit (Tokatli, 2008). To compare production in Europe and Asia,
Europe’s labor is higher than Zara by about 15- 20%, Asia countries are far but the
labor cost is cheaper and crowder. Zara procures the more price-sensitive but less time-
sensitive basic category apparel products by outsourcing total production processes to
OEM production/full package sourcing networks located in distant sources such as
China, Bangladesh, India, Pakistan, Vietnam and Cambodia where labor wage rates are
lower and order-to-delivery lead times are significantly longer compared to
local/proximate sourcing (Ferdows et al., 2004; Inditex Annual Report, 2005).
3.2. Internal Manufacture
The internal manufacturing is performed by 11 fully owned plants, most of them
positioned in and around Zara’s headquarters in Arteixo, Northern Spain (Amed &
Abnett, 2015) and (Inditex Annual Report, 2017). The manufacturing facilities are
automated and only perform in the capital-intensive initial production like fabric
dyeing; pattern design using CAD; creating layout of pattern pieces, cutting fabric by
automate knives and lasers aided by computer aided manufacturing (CAM). These
machines can calculate how to position the layout of pattern pieces on the marker
efficiently and quickly on computer screens to map out the individual parts for a
garment on the fabric. The machine thus minimizes fabric waste while cutting over 100
layers of cloth at single cut (Ghemawat & Nueno, 2006; McAfee et al., 2007).
After the fabrics are cutted, it will be sent to a network of more than 400-450 partner
factories located nearby the Inditex-owned factories in Galicia and Portugal to perform
the labor intensive assembly/sewing operations. Zara attentively monitors their
partner’s operation to safeguard quality, conformity with labor laws, and above
all else adherence to the production schedule. Zara and its subcontractors are generally
long-term and as such Zara collaborates with its subcontracting partners by providing 12 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
technology, logistics and financial support. After that, the partner factories then bring
back the assembled items to Zara’s factories, where each piece is inspected for
quality control during ironing, given a machine-readable tag and packaged. The
finished products are then dispatched on hangers grouped by model and size, through
part of the 211 km network of rails to Zara’s Arteixo distribution center. Completed
products procured from external suppliers are also sent directly to the distribution
center. Zara implements a sampling methodology to ensure quality for the incoming
products (Ghemawat & Nueno, 2006).
4. Logistics and Distribution
Logistics entails the free circulation of commodities from production units to target 1
customer for total satisfaction. It incorporates the integration of information, movement
of goods, stocking, storage, casing, and safety (Gelder & Woodcock, 2003). Zara has
successful logistics that totally commits to the customer's satisfaction. The effectiveness
of time and location are enhanced by its logistics. The business makes sure that clothing
is sent from its production facility in a timely manner to different outlets throughout the
world. It takes into account the constantly shifting fashion and trends that affect the
textile sector, enduring the constantly shifting consumer needs. Depending on the
requirements and market niche of that particular region, the logistics department
considers supplying different retailers with a variety of supplies. The company's
manufacturing operations are described in the following details: Instead of focusing on
low prices and cheap labor, Zara competes on flexibility and agility. Compared to the
average labor cost in Asia, which is roughly 0.40 euros per hour, they employ about
3,000 people in manufacturing operations in Spain at an average cost of 8.00 euros per
hour. Flexible manufacturing systems are used in the Spanish Zara facilities to facilitate
quick operational changes: 50% of all items are manufactured in Spain, 26% in the rest
of Europe, 24% in Asia and Africa.
Due to Zara's robust distribution network, products may be delivered to its European
stores in less than 24 hours and to its American and Asian locations in under 40. The
Cube and the company's headquarters are both in northwest Spain, which is the region's
center for manufacturing. However, they went with a location that is more centrally
positioned for its primary distribution and logistical hub. That facility is situated in a
sizable logistics hub built by the Spanish government in Zaragoza. Suppliers deliver raw 13 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
materials to Zara's production facility. After that, finished clothing is removed from
the Cube and delivered to the Zara logistics center in Zaragoza. From there, they are
transported by truck and by airplane.
PART C: Zara supply chain management issues and practices
I.Relationship management 1. Issues
Lack of Supplier Relationship Management brings Zara under fire. Reports from major
publications, such as Newsweek, have accused Zara of not paying its employees.
Stakeholders and advocates for human rights have expressed their displeasure with this. (Newsweek, 2017) 2. Practices
Managing supplier relationships - and ensuring procurement and sourcing activities are
completed ethically - is now more important than ever. Zara's trust-based and power-
based relationships with suppliers have allowed the company to operate with virtually few inventory in the process.
“According to the AP news agency, one of the factories owned by a Turkish Zara
company, Bravo, has been accused of not paying employees on time, if any” (Kaye,
2017). Zara customers find notes from unpaid employees inside their clothes. This lack
of relationship management regarding these external entities has once again put Zara in the hot seat.
In 2017, Zara signed an agreement with the International Labor Organization to
develop "best practices" in its factories and working conditions. However, just a month
later, these accusations surfaced and Zara did not make any public statements regarding
the allegations about their activities in Bravo factories. 3. Recommendations
Zara takes the fact that suppliers and manufacturers are the foundations of any business
extremely seriously and cares equally for its suppliers and producers. It effectively 14 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
protects the human rights of workers who toil away to make those stylish garments a
reality. Zara's long-term business model contributes to the development and prosperity
of its suppliers. As a result, it has a favorable impact in a number of countries. Zara
also works to promote international labor conventions. It demonstrates how the
corporation not only cares about its customers, but also for its suppliers and producers.
After all, Zara would be nothing without its employees at all levels.
II. Inventory Management 1. Issues
When applying lean production, Zara faces inventory management issues that mean
improving their supply chain and running it in a short time (about 15 days/new product)
while controlling operating and inventory costs as low as possible. 2. Practices
This model is used to minimize the cost to determine the purchasing as well as repairing
of lot sizes, predicts the sales in the store throughout the replenishment period, reduces 15 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
the shipment time, boosts the proportion of time that the products of Zara spend
on exhibit in their lifecycle. Thus, regarding competitors, Zara's inventory level is the lowest.
Firstly, Zara launches only small batch productions (lean concept) in order to reduce the
risks of producing something the customer doesn’t want. Thus, they reduced the
number of unsold clothes and practiced less markdowns than the others which increased the profit margin.
Moreover, Zara employs postponement for instance half of the products are undyed
until the last moment to select the color. That method decreases the components stock
and avoids forecasting mistakes.
Furthermore, it sometimes occurs that a product is sold well in one country but not in
another one, Zara uses reverse logistics by moving stocks from a store to another one
in order to place this product in a country where the sales will be higher. Stores place
orders twice a week and they don’t keep stock in the stores which decreases the stock
level as well. They can do that because of the speed of replenishment (within 24 hours in European countries). 3. Recommendations
Quick response (QR) began in the apparel industry as a response to JIT practices of the
auto industry. Zara should continue to develop a QR strategy that is based on shortening
the lead time from product design to store display because it allows the supply chain to
enter the seasonal sales cycle with a small initial inventory allocation at the retailers,
observe early sales patterns, generate a posterior demand distribution, and choose the
optimal replenishment quantity to maximize expected profits given the posterior
distribution. In this manner, Zara's planned stock-outs become a marketing advantage,
and they also avoid inventory obsolescence costs by quickly responding to changes in the marketplace.
Zara should be more careful about the way it deploys the latest IT tools to facilitate
information exchanges and apply advances of Technologies to produce more in less
time. A small change in retail orders can result in wide fluctuations in factory orders
after it's transmitted through wholesalers and distributors. In an industry that 16 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
traditionally allows retailers to change a maximum of 20% of their orders once the
season has started, Zara lets them adjust 40-50% => Zara can avoid costly over
production and the subsequent sales and discounting prevalent in the industry III. Reserve Logistics
The Zara organization makes some improvement in their supply chain and lastly they go
for reverse logistics of their clothes to become more sustainable. 1. Issues
Zara’s customers return products to different locations around the world
=> The collection and redemption process to reuse, recycle or refurbish old products takes time and is complicated. 2. Practices
Zara uses reverse logistics by moving stocks from a store to another one to place them
in a country where the sales will be higher, buying their old clothes for a small price
to reuse or organizing the reverse logistics for the returning parcels and re-introducing
them back to the commercial circuit.
In fact, as the clothes are fast-fashion items, basically, they quickly become “has-
been”. Zara could buy their old clothes for a small price to reuse the material. Zara
could create a closed loop by bringing back the products from the point of consumption
to the point of origin. Both Zara and customers would be winners. For sure, this
solution is hard to implement. If Zara organizes the reverse logistics for the returning
parcels and re-introducing them, The returned package needs to be opened and checked,
the clothes probably ironed, refolded and repacked. Then they need to be sent back to the usual logistic flow.
In short, dealing with ‘revitalizing’ clothes implies a cost (in money and time). Time
devoted to returning shipping, revitalizing clothes, and introducing the items again to
logistic-commercial flow means losing the freshness of trendy products, which have
‘‘expiration date’’ approach by the minute. This is especially troublesome in the case of Zara. 17 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01 3. Recommendations
In the long-term,Zara should work with third party transportation suppliers who are
close to its retail locations and are knowledgeable with the local transit infrastructure.
They will know the best way for faster delivery when having a product transported in
a local location that may have traffic jams or geographical difficulties. Furthermore,
buyers who are interested in Zara items and want to buy in quantity can choose a third
party to provide things to them as quickly as possible. In addition, Zara should widely
promote the campaign to recall old products for recycling in parallel with the launch of
a new collection to attract and stimulate buying psychology. IV. Forecasting 1. Overview
Zara's method is reactive, responding to market demand before it happens, which gives
Zara the possibility of planning ahead for styles and quantity. Zara forecasting strategy
focuses on responding to customer demands in a timely and cost-effective manner.
Zara's strategy also focuses on acquiring and provides the company with the vital
information it needs to stay competitive. They are quick on tech innovation and
even quicker on customer reactivity.
Trend forecasting allows Zara to keep close tabs on its customers’ desires in real
time. Customer’s demand is their priority . Besides, they want to ensure that the
right product is available in the right place at the right time. This strategy helps the
company to reduce costs and boost sales. Specifically, the forecasting process takes
into account both the internal and external factors that can affect consumer demand (McCann & Husmini, 2017). 2. Issues
Zara is quite active in releasing collections every few weeks. This way ensures to
keep customers coming back and keep designers aware of client feedback and
demand. However, it puts the burden on the inventory due to shortages and out-of-
stock situations (Mollard, 2020). They have difficulties making short-term forecast 18 lOMoARcPSD|45316467 Group 12 | INS 3021 01
judgments since they have to process large amounts of quantitative data such as initial
stock shipments to retailers, inventory replenishment, liquidation pricing, and supplier
purchase quantities. Furthermore, these choices are sometimes in the hands of a few
professionals. If they depart, it will create serious problems for the organization (Clegg, 2015).
Zara lags behind in AI-powered trend forecasting. They are unable to extend their
significant market share in e-commerce as a result of this (Gosselin, 2020). Actual e-
commerce demand is different from offline demand. It made product planning, design
development, garment production, and resource sharing
problematic. This results in higher production costs and autonomous development
while still consuming supplier capacity (Song, 2021). 3.
Zara implement forecasting
By forecasting trend behaviors and obtaining the data it can help merchandising and
planning teams align with design teams to adjust quantities, this will help Zara to focus
more on other strategies like reducing the amount of time for introducing new products .
Trend forecasting can be a practical way for Zara’s collection planning strategy. Zara’s
Quantitative analysis of social channels deep dives into consumer needs, and
this technology can predict trends up to one year in advance.
Zara's demand forecasting tends to be customer-centric, it helps Zara sustain and retain
competitive advantages over other rivals. Sales tracking data allows Zara to cater to its
customers with new trends and eliminate designs that do not appeal to customers. They
collect real-time data from e-commercial and store it through PDA , POS , RFID tag, and SKU’s.
To deal with qualitative data problems, Zara has developed Operations Research
and Information Technology divisions. These will find ways to deal
with the input data and use the optimization model to give the most accurate
forecast results (Clegg, 2015). Zara’s design team looks at sales data from stores
around the world to forecast what will be top-selling items and adjust
designs accordingly. They also receive qualitative feedback from in-store employees .
Moreover, collecting real data is helpful to forecast the amount of quantities and price
points for the new designs (Uberoi, 2017). To solve the problems of 19